BUSINESS ARTICLE ARCHIVE

Sharing Your Sweet Success: Commission Agreements

Stacks of paper against a light blue screen
Contracts 101

It is said that success is sweeter if you share it with others. For playwrights, the people who help represent your work also share in your success. “An agent’s task and need and want is to make you as much money as possible, because the agent doesn’t make money unless you make money,” Mitch Douglas of ICM once said. But just how much should you share with your publisher, agent, or manager?

Agency agreements are at the heart of this question, and understanding these agreements can help you decide whom you want to represent your work. Unless these agreements are specifically limited in scope, all income related to your professional career is subject to commission, so it is important to know how much you are expected to share and with whom. The last thing you want is to give permission for someone to take too big a piece of your success.

ARE PUBLISHERS COMMISSIONED?

Chances are your first major interaction with an agreement that involves a commission will be with a publishing house. The publisher takes a commission for licensing the acting edition of a work for performance.

Most major publishing agreements will want publishing and performance rights for the duration of your copyright in the work. To emphasize, the publisher obtains a license for the duration of your copyright. Do not sell your copyright to your publisher! While you will receive royalties from the retail sales of your published play (typically 10% of the retail sale price), the Guild cautions against relations where a publisher purchases your work outright and pays you royalties for the licensing alone.

In a typical publishing agreement, your publisher retains a commission anywhere from 10% to 50% of licensing fees for stock and professional productions and anywhere from 20% to 50% for amateur productions. Sometimes, the publisher will include a clause for licensing work in foreign territories, with a commission of 20% or more, since the publisher usually has a subagent in a foreign territory with whom they split the commission (i.e., 10% to subagent, 10% to publisher).

Additionally, in any licenses for publication of a collection of scenes or monologues (anything other than the acting edition), the commission is usually split, with half the publishing proceeds going to the publisher and half to you. The publishing house assesses the value it believes it will contribute to your play and drafts a commission agreement to reflect how much work they believe will be necessary to give your play the exposure it needs. No matter what the agreement, it is important to think of your publisher as your agent, who works for the advancement of your work. You are sharing with them, not the other way around.

HOW MUCH DO I SHARE WITH MY AGENT?

If you are an emerging writer with some festivals, contests, or small productions under your belt, it may be time to consider getting an agent – someone whose relationships in the theatrical community will be instrumental in securing your next production. According to the Association of Authors' Representatives, an agent can offer editorial guidance, establish contacts for you with firms that acquire rights to your dramatic material, advise you about current trends, market your work, negotiate and review licensing agreements, review royalty statements, and monitor the licensees’ overall treatment of your work. [For more on agents, see Bryan Kaplan’s article “Representation” in the Guild’s online article archive or the AAR website,www.aar-online.org.]

Contractual relationships with an agent typically come in two flavors. One flavor encompasses the development of your entire body of work for a specified time, typically any- where from one to three years. The other flavor is in connection to a specific work, either as a standalone contract or as an agency clause in a production contract. No matter the form of your agreement, it should clearly dictate the services you expect to receive and the agent’s percentage. While your agent only makes money if you make money, you want the best terms possible – you could conceivably be sharing with this person for a very long time.

The AAR recommends that a writer ask a number of questions of potential representation before signing an agreement, including: What are your commission rates? What are your procedures and timeframes for processing and disbursing client funds? What are your policies about charging clients for expenses incurred by your agency?

Customarily, an agent receives 10% of an author’s gross compensation for any professional or stock productions, increasing to 20% for amateur productions. These commissions come from any contracts entered during the time your agent represented you or those substantially negotiated by the agent and then subsequently signed in a finite amount of time after your relationship with your agent has ended (usually no more than one year).

Alternatively, if your contract with an agent is tied to a specific play rather than your entire body of work, the agent will probably want to insert an “agency clause” in the production contract, entitling the agent to a commission on any royalties derived from presentations of the work for the life of your copyright on that work. However, be aware that this clause will bind your agent to the work even if he no longer represents you. So, it is important that you agree to such a clause only for a significant production and that the clause requires the agent to continue to provide services to obtain the commission.

In addition to the commission your agent receives, your agreement may also entitle him to reimbursement of expenses incurred during the course of representation. A requirement to reimburse for costs and expenses should always be explicit in your agreement and can be drafted to come out of your royalties earned from contracts negotiated by the agent rather than your entire pool of income. It may be in your best interest to limit reimbursable expenses to some amount per expense (e.g., $200 or less) or to a yearly aggregate (e.g. $1,000/year), requiring your approval for all additional expenses. This will help mitigate ever-expanding office expenses eating away your future royalties.

Agents will reap the rewards of any negotiations or relationships they developed on your behalf by way of their commission. But, be cautious of language that broadly defines what actions constitute a commissionable service. For example, language that includes mere introductions as a commissionable service is unusually broad and overreaching. Commission proceeds should arise from contracts or negotiations more explicitly construed.

Additionally, some agents may charge upfront fees to review your work. While this practice is legal, the AAR’s canon of ethics states that it reflects poorly on the profession, and members of AAR are prohibited from charging such fees. Whether you choose to solicit an agent that charges a fee or not is a personal choice, but be aware that upfront fees are not indicative of the level of effect an agent can have on your career. [See the Nov/Dec 1999 Newsletter article “Pay or Play.”]

WHAT IF I HAVE A PERSONAL MANAGER?

If you are not getting as much time with your agent as you wish or are having trouble finding an agent or a publisher on your own, you may choose to hire a manager or management company. Though unable to obtain employment for you like an agent, a personal manager can provide you advice and act as a liaison among agents, attorneys, and other professionals to support your work.

Whereas the industry standard for an agent’s commission is 10% of your gross earnings, commission clauses for personal managers can reach as high as 25%. This commission does not decrease, even though you might also be paying your agent. If you choose to work with a personal manager, make sure he is experienced in theater before signing over the rights to have your career managed.

Though some managers may be members of the National Conference of Personal Managers (which prohibits its members from accepting a fee on the mere promise to obtain engagements for clients), manager commissions are not regulated. Keep in mind, however, that a literary agent does not need to be an “employment agent” and is not necessarily licensed or regulated either.

In fact, a manager is permitted to license your property just like an agent can but generally charges a higher commission. The Guild advises against a manager’s commission of more than 15% or a commission not otherwise reducible if a separate agent for film or television work is retained. [See Suzy Rose Yengo’s article “Do You Need a Manager” in the Guild’s online article archive.]

Personal managers sometimes provide clients with money for living expenses while both await “the big break.” Such risks and sacrifices are not necessarily expected of each personal manager and the extent of this type of financial commitment should be clear from the start – in writing. A management contract, as with the agent’s contract described above, will provide for a monthly expense ceiling, which the manager is allowed to charge to the artist’s account. Unlike an agent’s contract, a good personal manager agreement will address whether loaned or advanced funds to, or on behalf of, the artist are the artist’s personal debt or repayable only from work connected with the manager’s efforts.

Because a manager does not negotiate or obtain employment for you, it can be difficult to determine what commission is due when his contract has terminated. In this situation, it may be better to work out a commission agreement that incorporates a calendared phase-out, where the post-termination commission decreases from, perhaps, 20% down to 10% after six months, then down to 5% after a year, and then to complete severance after that. Finally, because the roles of manager and agent often overlap, carefully consider the necessity for retaining and paying for so much representation. Consider whether it is really worth it to pay 10% to agent and 20% to manager if you can deal directly and solely with your agent and get the proper attention without having to share more of your success.

OVERLAPPING COMMISSIONS AND THE DANGER OF DOUBLE-DIPPING

One of the most common dangers of having multiple parties representing your work is multiple commissions for the same deal, a pitfall known as “double-dipping.” For example, if your agent negotiates a deal with a licensing/publishing house, his commission for the publishing deal comes out of the commission payable to the publisher, not as a second commission payable by you on top of the publisher’s commission. The best way to avoid double-dipping is to be precise in the language of your publishing agreements, e.g., with regard to print publication agreements entered, the agent shall receive his share solely from, and not in addition to, the share of the fee payable by you to the stock or amateur subagent/licensor/publisher, with such share as the agent and the publisher may agree upon between themselves.

Another detail to make clear is that commissions for subagents (such as agents for foreign territories, movies, or television) are taken from the commission you pay your agent, not paid on top of your agent’s commission. Language that states the commission percentage is “inclusive of any obligations to subagents” is often appropriate. Sometimes an agent will charge a higher commission because these subagents are rolled into the services provided. Some publishing houses may even charge a higher commission if they are offering additional services, like an in-house attorney (for contract review and counseling).

Also, keep in mind that, even though you may have obtained new representation, your work may still be generating a commission for your former agent, in perpetuity. In such circumstances, which are not at all uncommon, your new agent can negotiate a deal with the former one wherein both agents agree to a “split commission” arrangement, giving 5% to each. This benefits both agents because your former agent earns 5% from a deal he will not have to do any work on, as opposed to earning 10% of the $0 revenues earned from a script of an ex-client sitting on the shelf. The new agent, though getting less than the customary commission for that one play, is investing in your career and can build upon your old contacts to make new contacts in the future for your other plays, for which he can earn a full commission. The new agent can also better control the licensing of your entire output.

COMMISSIONS FOR ENTERTAINMENT ATTORNEYS?

Like managers, most entertainment attorneys are not licensed to seek employment for you. However, a well-connected attorney can recommend you for specific assignments. While an attorney can charge hourly for advice on general matters, when negotiating terms for a specific deal, he may instead take a commission from your gross income earned as a result of the negotiation. This commission is typically 5%. This will likely save you money upfront because you will not be charged for the time your attorney puts into negotiating the best terms for you, but it could end up a more expensive arrangement in the long run.

Additionally, you may choose to work with an agent also licensed to practice law. For the privilege of both agency and legal services, you may see commissions up to 15% (10% for the agent commission and 5% for the legal expertise).

CONCLUSION

Remember that with each additional member you add to your professional entourage of agents, publishers, and managers, a percentage of your revenue leaves with them. Weigh carefully the benefits and necessity of each relationship and make agreements that make sense in terms of time with the agent and breadth of her services. The Dramatists Guild Resource Directory includes many play publishers, attorneys, and agents that are experienced in theater. While there are benefits to sharing your success, the last thing you want is to have encumbered your work so much that it becomes unlicenseable and sits on your ex-agent’s shelf as “inventory.”

Ashley Kelly, the Dramatists Guild Business Affairs intern, is a graduate of Barnard College and currently attending Brooklyn Law School.

PUBLISHING HOUSE V. COPYRIGHT DURATION