BUSINESS ARTICLE ARCHIVE

Pay or Play: A Playwright’s Guide to Cons, Scams, Swindles, and Other Typical Behavior

Stacks of paper against a light blue screen
Markets

One morning, I came into my office at the Guild and thumbed through the latest issue of The Dramatist. I noticed two related articles in the news section about New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer’s convictions of several “publishers” and “literary agents” for defrauding writers. [See “Fraud Charges Upheld” and “Online Agency Closed” in The Dramatist September/October issue.] Later that day, I learned that an agent on the Guild’s Los Angeles office list of Southern California Literary agents charges $45 per hour to read submissions. After I came back from lunch, I received my second complaint within a week about letters sent by the theatre company Theatre Studio Inc. to playwrights, asking for $300 from the writer to produce their plays “in full-length form.” Before I left for the night, a member called me on the business affairs hotline to review a publishing agreement that required the writer to pay publishing expenses.

Needless to say, it was a bad day, but certainly not as bad a day for me as for those of you who had fallen victim to various cons, scams, swindles, and behavior that might be described as “exploitative” or “predatory.” However, let me be clear: not everyone is a con artist… though it sometimes may seem that way. There are legitimate professionals out there, from typists to dramaturgs to musical arrangers, who render services to writers for a fee. They make no claims about the play’s “producibility”; nor do they “represent” or “publish” you. Their opinion will not get you a producer, and they don’t imply that it will.

Then, there are others. The agent who requires a “reading” fee. The publisher who refers you to an “editor” before rejecting your work or who accepts your work but asks you to pay the publishing costs. The theatre, festival, or contest with an exorbitant entry fee. The “experts” who offer unsolicited “help” getting your work published or produced – for a price. There is an endless parade of people trying to exploit your naiveté, fear, insecurity, and desperation and to parlay them into a lucrative career for themselves. Luckily for writers, these people sometimes are caught. In the case of the Woodside Literary Agency of Queens, NY, it was found to have misled its clients and misrepresented its services by luring writers with positive evaluations of writing samples, then imposing charges for further review and processing of manuscripts. Woodside was ordered to stop its internet publishing scheme, provide restitution to consumers, pay penalties and costs to New York State, and post a $100,000 bond to protect future consumers.

In the case of Edit Ink, this network of co-conspirators from New York to California were convicted of operating a scheme to defraud writers into spending thousands of dollars for editing costs only to have their manuscripts rejected by phony publishing companies and literary agents. The State Appellate Division upheld $2 million in civil penalties for their fraudulent acts, false advertising, and deceptive business practices. However, there remains a wide range of literary stings, so I thought it would be useful to make note of some activities of which writers should be wary and to offer a caution about behaviors that should give a dramatist pause.

Agents

The Association of Authors’ Representatives is a trade association of over 275 literary and dramatic agents. Their Canon of Ethics prohibits members from charging fees for reviewing a writer’s work. Since anyone may call himself or herself a literary agent and there is no requirement that an agent join ARR, such fees are not illegal but merely viewed by ARR and most writers, editors, and publishers as unprofessional and, sometimes, unethical.

According to Jim Fisher’s Fisher Report(a pamphlet on how to find legitimate agents and how to avoid unethical practices and practitioners) and Scott Edelstein’s book 100 Things Every Writer Needs to Know, some of the fee schemes include the following:

READING FEES: Some agents charge reading fees and don’t take on clients, just manuscripts. They offer generic “evaluations” of little value and rarely attempt to sell any scripts. Other agents who are sincere about representing clients may still be considered unprofessional for charging reading fees.

CONTRACT FEES: Some agents charge an up-front fee (sometimes even annually) to represent a writer. FEES FOR SERVICE: Some agents charge a flat fee for each submission they make on the writer’s behalf, rather than take the usual commission on sales.

EDITING FEES: Some agents and book doctors charge $1,000 to $2,000 for “editing” that may be mere boilerplate comments, which guarantee nothing and even may be detrimental to your work.

KICKBACKS: Some agents receive kickbacks from freelance “editors” and book doctors for referring writers to them. Some agents even receive additional money for placing ads to lure clients.

Both Fisher and Edelstein say you should be suspicious of agents who are secretive about their clients or recent sales; offer positive but vague praise for your work; or issue glossy brochures about their agency, advertise for clients, or make unsolicited offers to represent you. The bottom line on agents is that, while most are legitimate professionals, some make more money from charging fees than from selling plays. You should scrupulously avoid the latter. [See “Representation” in the December 1997 Newsletter.]

Publishers

Often working in conjunction with unscrupulous “agents” is an array of “publishers” of whom writers also need to be wary. On one hand, there is the “vanity press,” which really is not a publisher but a printer that will print your play the way you want, completely at your expense. While there is nothing illegal or unethical about such enterprises (as long as their nature is fully disclosed), there is also no benefit to them, since everyone knows who they are and your association with them offers no prestige or legitimate credential

On the other hand, there are “subsidy” or “co-publishing” deals, in which you pay a portion of publishing costs or guarantee the sale of a number of books. Bookstores and libraries know which publishing houses are subsidy and/or vanity presses and generally do not carry their goods. Further, play publishing really is about play licensing, and subsidy and vanity presses will not generate any licenses for your play. Since publishers do little if anything to promote your material or enhance its reputation. In fact, the quality of the actual printing, if the play even is published at all, may be inferior. A similar problem exists for songwriters who have their music “published” and recorded, then end up paying for an apartment full of CDs.

A better choice than vanity publishing is self-publishing, but this is viable only if you have the time, energy, expertise, and resources to devote to the undertaking. Unless marketing and sales are your forte, unless you’re adept at negotiating agreements, this may be a dangerous venture for you. [To read more about standard publishing arrangements, see “To Print or Not to Print” in the January/February 1999 Newsletter.]

Producers

In a letter to a Guild member, Artistic Director A. M. Raychel of Theatre Studio Inc., a New York City company, wrote, “I have found a growing audience resistance to the traditional, full-length play. Therefore, the likelihood of full production of your play in full-length form is virtually nil. For this reason, we encourage playwrights to adapt/edit their work in a workshop format… If, however, you wish to undertake a fully staged reading of your play in full-length form, your play will be solely responsible for audience development. Therefore, we require a $300 deposit.” In addition, this company requires the author to pay $50 to place an ad to find a director.

As questionable as Raychel’s request is, it is just one thing to be wary about producing groups. Festivals, contests, workshops, and other producing ventures are charging an ever-growing rash of reading fees, application fees, and participation fees. Sometimes, you pay just to have these groups read and consider your play, without even the promise of a prize or production. If your work is accepted, you may be asked to pay an application fee to have your work judged, entered, or whatever nomenclature pertains. The goal seems to be to generate profits (or at least cash flow) from simply processing manuscripts while minimizing any risk inherent in producing.

Producers naturally try to shift the risks and burdens of production onto anyone, including the writer, willing to take them on; however, this movement seems to be gaining popularity in the nonprofit and fringe festival arenas. In addition to reading fees and application fees, festivals ask you to pay participation fees for the right to be permitted to self-produce your work in their program. Some festivals, including the New York Fringe Festival, even take a share of your box office receipts and a percentage of your subsidiary rights. The famed Edinburgh Fringe Festival, though, does not operate this way, nor do many other reputable festivals that follow Edinburgh’s lead. [For more on this topic, see “Writers on the Fringe” in the June/July 1998 Newsletter.]

Conclusion

Beware of anyone who wants your money to read, represent, publish, or produce your work. Such people may be unprofessional, unethical, and possibly fraudulent. Share your concerns with us by writing a letter outlining the troubling behavior and troublesome parties you have encountered, so we can maintain files of such activities and advise or warn our members accordingly. If we can accomplish that, when closing my office door and turning off my light, I’ll know the day wasn’t so bad after all.

The Fisher Scale

The Fisher Scale is a numeric rating that adds points for certain suspicious activities and allows you to quantify the risks of dealing with certain agents.

POINTS ADVICE: Using this scale, if the point score adds up to: (1-2) Be Careful; (3-4) Be Suspicious; (5-7) Proceed at Your Own Risk; (8 and up) Avoid.

IF THE AGENCY: 

POINTS 

Is not located in New York City, Chicago, or Los Angeles 

1 

Is not a member of the Association of Authors’ Representatives 

1 

Is not currently listed in The Literary Marketplace 

1 

Has a post office box for an address 

1 

Advertises in writer’s magazines for clients 

3 

Charges reading or evaluation fees 

3 

Treats its recent sales list as confidential 

3 

Solicits manuscripts by mail 

3 

Asks for marketing, contract, representation, handling, processing, retainer, or circulation fees 

3 

Lists, as recent sales books, published by firms that require authors to pay part or all of the publishing costs or to buy a large number of their own books 

4 

Offers line editing services for a fee 

5 

Refers rejected manuscripts to freelance book doctors 

5 

Owns or has a financial interest in a subsidy publishing company 

6 

The curated DG Business Advice and Glossary Library is a members-only compilation of current and frequently used Business Affairs articles, terms and videos on issues pertaining to collaboration, copyright, contracts, free speech, underlying rights, and many more.